Committee makes permanent SSA‑to‑Treasury Do Not Pay death‑data sharing; heated oversight debate over alleged data exposure
Loading...
Summary
The committee voted to make permanent SSA sharing of state death records with Treasury's Do Not Pay system (HR 27 16). Debate included technical safeguards but also a sustained cross‑aisle fight over allegations that a contractor and a private team copied SSA records to an insecure cloud and whether the committee should pursue oversight hearings.
The Ways and Means Committee voted to report HR 27 16, a bill to permanently permit the Social Security Administration to share state death records with the Treasury Department's Do Not Pay working system in order to prevent improper payments to deceased individuals.
Committee staff said the pilot program begun in December 2023 produced measurable returns — the Bureau of Fiscal Service reported roughly $109 million in identified improper payments prevented in the first year — and described data integrity provisions the substitute adds, including a clear‑and‑convincing evidence standard before a record is added as deceased and procedures for correcting erroneous records.
The markup became the venue for a broader, heated discussion about program integrity and data security. Multiple members, including Representatives Larson and Doggett, cited whistleblower claims that a contractor team (named in the transcript as "Doge") had copied SSA records to a cloud environment they described as insecure. Ranking Member Larson and others repeatedly pressed for oversight hearings and for the committee to compel testimony from the contractor and from Elon Musk (whose firm was identified in the context of the transcript during questioning). Rep. Larson said, "a whistleblower comes forward and says that Doge has copied the personal and confidential information of every single American to a vulnerable and insecure cloud."
Supporters said permanency will help other agencies reduce improper payments and save taxpayer dollars and emphasized the bill includes data‑integrity protections. Opponents and many Democrats pressed for immediate oversight of data handling and for restoring or replacing watchdog functions; members asked for IG and contractor disclosures before or in parallel with implementation.
After debate the committee adopted the substitute and voted to report HR 27 16 favorably (41‑0). The committee also recorded a longer discussion on oversight and requested follow‑up actions; multiple members sought hearings on the alleged data exposure and staffing/inspector‑general issues at SSA.
What’s next: HR 27 16 will be reported to the House. Several members said they will continue to press the committee for oversight hearings about the data handling allegations and for restoration of inspector‑general functions in the agency.
