Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Historic Preservation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves window-replacement plan at 49 Florentine amid lead-paint debate
Summary
Owners seeking to remediate lead paint and replace deteriorated windows at 49 Florentine Gardens presented a plan the commission approved after hearing substantial public comment weighing preservation against child-safety and housing access concerns. Commissioners emphasized preserving front-facing historic character where feasible.
Owners’ representatives told the commission the house at 49 Florentine Gardens contains extensive lead paint and that licensed mitigation work will begin in January; contractors told the applicants that fully removing lead from the existing sash would likely destroy many frames, so applicants proposed installing vinyl 4-over-1 replacement windows and encapsulating or preserving key visual details where possible (SEG 2062–2210).
Neighbors and preservation advocates urged alternatives: restoration, saving the diamond-pane upper sash, or using interior replacement methods to retain visible historic character while addressing lead hazards (public comments at SEG 2620–2710). Supporters argued replacement was necessary to enable a young family to return and to remove a major health hazard.
Commissioners examined tradeoffs between character-defining features and public health. Several suggested partial solutions (retain or protect most prominent front-window detail, investigate restoration contractors who can strip and restore windows). The commission voted to accept the application as presented, with discussion recorded about preserving prominent front details where practicable; one commissioner voted no (recorded dissent noted in roll call) (SEG 2889–2910).
