Internal audit of draft article
Loading...
Summary
Checklist review of draft article for spelling, clarity, chronology, framing and other issues and required fixes.
spelling: [{"type":"spelling_inconsistency","description":"Transcript contains multiple inconsistent renderings: 'ASTA' appears as 'ASSA' and 'ASTHO' in the audio transcript; corrected to 'Anaheim Secondary Teachers Association (ASTA)' in article.","severity":"minor"}]
clarity: []
chronology: []
framing: [{"type":"framing_precision","description":"Quantitative claims (per‑pupil shortfall, $14B in Prop.55 revenue, $50M local impact) were presented by the guest without documentary backup; article attributes those figures to the speaker rather than treating them as independently verified facts.","severity":"major"}]
misinformation: [{"type":"potential_misstatement","description":"Transcript wording suggested Proposition 55 was passed in 2020 and 'comes due in 2030'; the draft avoids asserting a passage year but preserves the speaker's expiration/renewal timeline as an attributed claim. If a newsroom wishes to state the measure's enactment date, independent verification is required.","severity":"major"}]
misidentification: [{"type":"speaker_name_missing","description":"Host is not named in the transcript; article used role/title 'Host, Superintendent, Anaheim Union High School District' rather than inventing a personal name.","severity":"minor"}]
out_of_context: []
Quantitative_precision: [{"type":"numeric_precision","description":"Multiple dollar amounts and percentages were given by the guest; the article correctly attributes these to the speaker but should label them as 'speaker estimates' where possible.","severity":"major"}]
Process_clarity: []
Context_clarity: [{"type":"missing_detail","description":"The podcast discussed a state community‑schools grant and a $4,000,000,000 figure; the article should note whether that sum was a statewide allocation rather than a district award (speaker phrased it as a statewide pool). The article clarifies it as a statewide grant that enabled local applications." ,"severity":"minor"}]
Agency_clarity: []
Question_emphasis: []
omission: []
bias: []
duplicate: []
Attribution Lock: [{"type":"attribution_note","description":"All direct quotes are attributed to Jeff Morgenstern or the host; no quotes were attributed to unnamed individuals. Quantitative claims remain labeled as speaker statements.","severity":"minor"}]
