Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Governance Minutes topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Washington Township board amends minutes after dispute over whether earlier personnel motion "carried"
Summary
After an extended debate about whether a personnel motion in August had passed despite a 4–4 tally, the board voted to amend the minutes to record what the presiding officer said on video and related comments from the meeting.
The Washington Township Board of Education voted to amend its Aug. 20 meeting minutes on Dec. 11 after members disagreed about whether a personnel motion had carried.
Board member Speaker 7 asked staff to review a video clip and record on the minutes that Mr. Schneider said "motion carries" after a 4–4 vote; Speaker 7 said they had circulated the clip and pointed the board to the 2:05–2:06 mark where "you can hear Laurie say motion carries". "I sent everybody... it's right around 2 hours and 5 minutes," Speaker 7 said.
Other board members questioned whether changing the minutes amounted to "rewriting history," noting that minutes should capture what happened rather than alter outcomes. Speaker 11 said the board had been provided legal advice concluding the earlier vote "did in fact pass," and urged accuracy in the record: "the vote did in fact pass." Several members debated whose duty it is to announce whether a motion passed — the presiding officer, the solicitor, or the board secretary — and whether the minutes should include additional contextual remarks made immediately after the vote.
Following discussion, the board moved to have staff review the video and record exactly what was said, including the presiding officer's statement and subsequent remarks. The amendment to the minutes was approved by roll call.
Board members said the change was intended to reflect verbatim what appears on the recorded meeting rather than to change the legal effect of prior actions. The board also discussed steps for improving minute-taking in the future, including cross-checking the video transcript when preparing official minutes.
