Split vote lets homeowner replace garage at historic 15 Lyman Street

The commission considered an application to remove and replace an accessory garage/carport at 15 Lyman Street, the Charles Newton second house, which the commission acknowledged as architecturally significant. Homeowner Kelly Seibler described the proposed replacement as sympathetic to the main house—cedar shingles on the upper gable, clapboard on the lower portion, matching ornamental brackets, and matching paint.

Seibler told the commission the existing structure is in disrepair, with a shallow foundation and deteriorated materials; contractors recommended teardown and rebuild. She said the existing covered portion measures roughly 20 feet deep by 24 feet wide and that the proposed new garage would be about 26 feet by 28 feet, moving two feet toward the center of the property.

Commissioners debated whether an accessory outbuilding of that vintage should be protected. Vice Chair Grant Farrington said he viewed the garage as historically significant and complementary to the main house, while Treasurer Annie Caff said she found no compelling historic or architectural qualities. Member Michelle said she was 'on the fence' but expected the proposed replacement would be sympathetic and not an eyesore.

Chair Kevin Miller moved to find the garage historically or architecturally significant and advance it to a public hearing; the motion, seconded by Grant Farrington, failed on a roll-call vote: Grant Farrington—Yes, Annie Caff—No, Michelle—No, Kevin Miller—No (1–3). Because the commission did not find significance, the applicant may proceed with the proposed replacement, subject to normal building and permitting requirements.

The commission discussed the option of a site visit or public hearing if members later believed preservation review was appropriate; no delay or further action was approved at this meeting.