Council divided over allowing Mine Shaft Road eastbound access during traction closures

A proposal to allow residents limited eastbound access from Mine Shaft Road during traction‑control closures drew sharp council debate at the Dec. 16 work session, with council members split over equity and precedent.

City Manager Jared summarized the request and noted Mine Shaft Road is currently closed by the police during traction‑control events; officers permit westbound turns for local access but have restricted eastbound access to prevent bypassing traction-control stations. "There's a request to allow access into the canyon from Mine Shaft Road," Jared said.

Several council members opposed a location‑specific exception. "I don't see it as an equitable practice to allow somebody to do something that nobody else can," one council member said, arguing that special privileges would invite similar requests across neighborhoods. Supporters said denying eastbound turns forces residents to make long detours and can add 30–40 minutes to local trips.

Chief Russo (public safety) and council members discussed enforcement, prior resident permit programs on other streets, and whether the city could craft a residency‑based permit or handle limited exceptions administratively. Multiple council members suggested further study and community input before taking action.

Outcome and next steps: Council did not adopt a final policy during the work session. Staff indicated the item will return for further discussion with options that more clearly explain enforcement, equity and operational impacts.