Audit of draft article and meeting extraction
Get AI-powered insights, summaries, and transcripts
Subscribe
Summary
Checklist review for spelling, clarity, chronology, framing and other issues; one substantive transcript-name inconsistency flagged (Knapp/Knopp).
This audit reviews the draft reporting and metadata against the Issues Rules checklist.
Spelling: Issue: inconsistent spelling of Parks director last name in transcript (appears as both "Knapp" and "Knopp"). Severity: medium. Description: transcript alternates between "Dave Knapp" (SEG 337) and ‘‘Knopp’’ (SEG 3097). Fix applied: used the first explicit appearance "Dave Knapp" as the canonical name in speakers and article; flagged for staff confirmation.
Clarity: []
Chronology: []
Framing: []
Misinformation: []
Misidentification: Issue: partial ambiguity of Chief Gordon / "Josh" identification (transcript shows role "Chief Gordon" and later speaker says "Josh is my name"). Severity: low. Description: article identifies the marine safety presenter as "Chief Josh Gordon" (role and given name combined) using transcript evidence; recommended confirmation in staff materials. Fix applied: kept both title and first name as reported by speaker.
Out_of_context: []
Quantitative precision: Issue: site maximum numbers discussed in transcript were presented as ranges and proposals (6,12,15,20,30). Severity: low. Description: article reports ranges and notes staff intent to set objective thresholds; where exact permanent numbers are unclear, text uses approximate phrasing and notes to-staff drafting.
Process clarity: []
Context clarity: []
Agency clarity: []
Question emphasis: []
Omission: []
Bias: []
Duplicate: []
Transcript Segment Error: []
Attribution Lock: []