Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Charter Amendments topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee reviews H.516 to update Essex town charter; counsel flags drafting clarifications
Summary
The House Government Operations & Military Affairs committee reviewed H.516, which would ratify seven voter-approved charter amendments for the town of Essex. Proposals include clarifying the moderator role, changing minutes approval timing, shifting some appointment authorities, and allowing flexible notice for the annual report; counsel flagged drafting consistency for vacancy/incapacity and minute-posting language.
The House Government Operations & Military Affairs committee met on Wednesday, Jan. 14, 2025, to consider H.516, an act implementing amendments to the town charter of Essex that Essex voters approved at a recent town meeting.
Essex town officials joined the committee by Zoom. Greg Duggan, Essex town manager, told the panel the town placed seven charter amendments on the ballot last March and that voters approved all seven. "We had 7 charter changes on the ballot, all of which were approved by voters," Duggan said, and asked the committee to move the approved items through the legislative review process.
The measures in H.516 mix technical cleanups with a few substantive updates. Key proposals described in the committee hearing include:
- Moderator duties: Amendments clarify the moderator's role now that Essex uses Australian ballot voting for town meeting business rather than floor votes. Duggan said the change separates moderator duties from select board responsibilities and addresses procedures for moderator incapacity.
- Minutes timing: The charter would replace language requiring minutes be "approved at the next select board meeting" with language that minutes "shall be approved by the select board as soon as is reasonably possible." Duggan said the town continues to post draft minutes within five days to comply with open meeting law. Representative Waters Evans asked whether the charter sets a specific number of days; Duggan answered it does not, but the town posts drafts within five days.
- Appointments: Several appointment authorities would shift to the select board. Duggan said the cemetery commission would move to select board appointment; the fire chief would be appointed by the town manager with select board approval. The draft also removes obsolete positions (grand juror, fire wardens, fence viewers, inspector of lumber and shingles) to defer to general statute where appropriate.
- Notice for annual/auditors' report: The proposed amendments would allow the town more flexibility in notifying residents that the annual auditors' report is available (such as a smaller mailed postcard or online availability) instead of mailing the full ~80-page annual report to every household. "It costs us about 10 or $11,000 to print that and mail it to every single household," Duggan said, arguing a shorter mailed notice could reduce wasted printing and postage.
- Department naming and appraisal language: The charter would rename the "department of real estate appraisal" to the "department of assessment" and add language requiring that appraisals be reviewed in accordance with state appraisal standards; the town's assessment department would have powers and liabilities comparable to listers under general law.
Legislative counsel Tucker Anderson walked the committee through the bill's technical provisions and several drafting issues. Anderson highlighted vacancy and incapacity language that defines incapacity, for purposes of triggering a vacancy, to include failure to attend at least 50% of select board meetings in a calendar year; he noted that the moderator subsection does not include incapacity and flagged that inconsistency for clarification. Anderson also cautioned that the charter phrase "as soon as is reasonably possible" may be ambiguous where the open meeting law prescribes a five-business-day posting requirement; he recommended specific drafting if the committee intended the charter to supersede or alter the statutory posting deadline.
Leonora Dodge, who identified herself for the record, pointed out an apparent drafting omission: the cemetery commission was added to the select board's appointment list but not removed from the town manager's appointment list in one section. Duggan acknowledged the omission and thanked Dodge for catching it.
No formal motions or committee votes were recorded during the hearing. Committee members said they would work with legislative counsel and the town to clarify the 50% attendance/incapacity wording and to refine the minutes-posting language so it aligns with open meeting requirements.
The committee concluded the session after noting the outstanding drafting flags, with staff and counsel to follow up on the specific textual fixes raised during the hearing.
