Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Quiet Zone topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Needham board signals plan to pursue seasonal closure of golf-course railroad crossing, defers immediate move
Summary
After a public comment from a resident heavily affected by train horns, the Needham Select Board directed staff to pursue planning and a public hearing on a seasonal closure of the golf-course railroad crossing but concluded a full pilot this season is unlikely; the town insurer raised two legal caveats for any agreement.
Resident Chris Supple asked the Select Board to pursue a winter pilot to close the golf-course railroad crossing so MBTA conductors would not sound horns at that location during nonemergencies. "...if the crossing is closed, they will tell the conductors don't have to blow the horn there in nonemergency situations," Supple said, and asked the town to consider either a temporary fencing or a continuous chain-link closure during the December–March pilot period.
Town Manager Katie Racer told the board the town's insurer reviewed the example MBTA agreement and found it would not change the town's insurance coverage provided two conditions are met: the town must not waive the Tort Claims Act liability cap and the MBTA must not be indemnified by the town. Racer framed the board's decision as one of timing and public engagement: "Is this something we want to do, and do you want a public hearing?" she said.
Director of Public Works Cara Sluss summarized operational options: either the golf course installs fencing or the town does it via an on-call fencing contractor; town installation would take roughly four weeks from an on-site meeting, a timeline that makes a March 1 pilot end difficult to achieve this season. Sluss noted the town has discretion about fencing type and that examples provided to Needham largely came from private ways.
Board members split between urgency and process. Several members—including one who said they were "sympathetic" to impacted residents—favored planning the work for next winter and holding a public hearing to gather both sides of public opinion. One member urged pursuing the pilot quickly if possible but acknowledged the limited six‑week window before the pilot end date. The board ultimately gave staff direction to prepare materials, work with the MBTA on an agreement, and schedule a public hearing on the topic at a future Select Board meeting rather than rushing to implement the pilot this season.
Next steps: staff will draft an agreement with the MBTA, clarify operational fence/gate specifics with the golf course, schedule a public hearing with the chair, and bring an item back to the Select Board with recommended language and a recommended timeline. The Select Board did not adopt a pilot implementation vote at this meeting.
