Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Consumer Protection Towing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee advances bill allowing retrieval of cell phones and work tools from impounded vehicles
Summary
A bill to expand the statute's list of 'life-essential' items to include cell phones and work tools was favorably recommended after testimony from criminal defenders and towing industry representatives; supporters said the change preserves livelihoods, while tow operators warned of unpaid fees and higher abandonment rates.
The Senate committee unanimously recommended SB 200, which would expand Utah's definition of "life-essential" items that may be retrieved from impounded vehicles to include cell phones and work tools. The sponsor framed the bill as a narrowly tailored change to prevent individuals from losing essential tools of their trade when a vehicle is towed.
Sponsor testimony recounted a client who lost tools and could not afford towing fees, leaving him unable to continue work. "It's good policy to ensure that an individual doesn't become destitute as a result of a tow," the sponsor said when explaining the bill’s origin. The bill would add a phone and work tools to the existing list of life-essential items in Utah code.
Public defenders and attorneys who contract with municipalities asked the committee to pass the bill so indigent clients could maintain livelihoods and comply with court-ordered programs. Adam Craig, managing partner at Stoll Craig—who said his firm holds towing contracts for 12 cities—urged support, noting that work tools and phones are necessary for clients to continue employment.
Towing-industry witnesses urged caution. Barbara Christiansen, president of the Utah Professional Towing Alliance, said industry stakeholders had previously negotiated the statutory list with the tax commission and warned that allowing more items to be taken from vehicles would increase abandonment rates and unpaid fees for tow companies. Brett Reeder of the Utah Towing Alliance echoed concerns about lost payment for services and potential disputes over missing items.
Committee members asked the sponsor to refine language and consult with stakeholders; Senator Winterton moved to forward the bill to the Senate floor and the committee recorded a unanimous favorable recommendation.
