Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Employee Benefits topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Clay County keeps medical plan largely unchanged; tables ancillary benefit decisions amid carrier comparisons
Summary
After a presentation by benefits consultant Rachel Baca, the board voted to renew the county medical plan with the same employee/employer contribution shares and a $1,500 deductible (3% rate increase). Discussion on dental, vision and other voluntary lines was tabled for a future meeting while staff seeks additional carrier details and provider-network reports.
Clay County commissioners on May 27 heard a detailed benefits renewal presentation from Rachel Baca of Marshalls Credit Agency and voted to renew the county’s medical plan with minimal plan design changes while deferring decisions on employee-paid ancillary lines.
Baca told the board the April 1 renewal showed a 3% increase from Wellmark and that the county’s most recent 12-month medical and pharmacy claims totaled about $718,000, down from $776,000 the prior period. "Your medical and pharmacy claims for the most recent experience period was 718,000," Baca said. She noted the county’s loss ratio is about 91% (carriers target 85%), four high-cost claimants exceed $50,000 (one about $85,000), and pharmacy spending is driving recent increases. Baca also walked through options such as raising the individual deductible from $1,500 to $2,000 (which she estimated could save roughly 4.5% for the county but would raise employee cost-sharing and copays).
During discussion commissioners weighed administrative disruption against cost savings. On a motion to renew the medical plan with the $1,500 deductible and keep contribution percentages the same, the board voted in favor; the motion passed on a voice vote. The board then moved to table a decision on employee-paid ancillary lines (dental, vision, voluntary life and short-term disability) so staff can run provider ZIP-code reports, obtain clarifying carrier quotes and present comparisons at the next meeting.
Baca presented comparative quotes showing potential employer savings on ancillary packages: examples given included Equitable estimated savings to the employer of about $10,850 and Mutual of Omaha savings around $7,062 (figures depend on final enrollment and plan design). She recommended caution about switching carriers solely for short-term savings, noting network disruptions and the administrative burden of frequent changes.
Next steps: staff will request provider-network reports for local ZIP codes, share updated quotes from Mutual of Omaha and other carriers, and return to the board with a recommendation for ancillary lines at the next meeting. The medical renewal will be processed consistent with the board motion.
