Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Housing Element RHNA topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Resident warns commission that housing-element overlays won’t meet RHNA goals
Summary
At the start of the Feb. 5 Planning Commission meeting, resident Jim Mosher told commissioners that Newport Beach may fall far short of its RHNA obligation — about 3,000 affordable units — and that recent court rulings limit use of overlays as a compliance mechanism.
During the public-comment period at the Feb. 5 Planning Commission meeting, local resident Jim Mosher told commissioners the city’s current approach to meeting Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) targets is not producing enough affordable units. Mosher said staff slides from a recent city-council planning session show overlays have yielded roughly 200 of the approximately 3,000 affordable units Newport Beach must plan for in the present RHNA cycle.
Mosher warned that at current production rates — where affordable units are being produced at roughly one per 20 market-rate units — the city lacks a realistic plan to meet its requirements and may need to rezone properties so redevelopment must produce affordable units rather than relying on overlays. He also referenced a recent California appeals-court opinion that the state Supreme Court declined to review, saying the ruling limits the ability to use overlays to meet affordable-housing obligations.
Staff did not provide a detailed rebuttal in the public-comment period; commissioners noted the issue and referenced an upcoming staff report on housing-element progress on the commission’s March agenda. Mosher raised the matter again later during the meeting while speaking on the Dover townhomes item, asking for clarity in the resolution about how the city will account for any shortfall when a site yields fewer units than the overlay potential.
The commission acknowledged the concern and listed the annual general-plan housing report and other housing-element items on future agendas; the transcript shows follow-up briefings and the subject remains open for further staff analysis and council review.
