Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Rezoning topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning commission recommends rezoning for 32‑lot Ranch Gate subdivision, citing preserved washes and added open space
Summary
The commission unanimously (7–0) recommended a zoning map amendment to allow a 32‑lot subdivision on about 40 acres (Ranch Gate 40). Staff and the applicant said clustering around wash corridors, added natural area open space, emergency access and DRB lighting review address neighborhood concerns about drainage, dark skies and traffic.
The Scottsdale Planning Commission unanimously recommended City Council approve a zoning district map amendment (ZN‑2024) to allow the Ranch Gate 40 subdivision, a 32‑lot single‑family project on roughly 40 acres in the Dynamite Foothills character area.
Staff (Jeff Barnes) said the proposal would change zoning from R1‑130 ESL to R1‑35 ESL and highlighted three wash corridors on the site, a 100‑foot‑average scenic corridor along 128th Street, and roughly 3.87 acres of natural area open space above the minimum requirement. The plan reduced an initial theoretical density from 41 lots (per zoning density) to a practical 32‑lot proposal through clustering and design adjustments.
Commissioners questioned lighting, dark‑sky impacts, traffic warrants and sewer capacity. Scottsdale traffic engineer John Huang (referred to in the transcript) said the single required intersection illumination would be about 7,000 lumens (roughly a 60‑watt equivalent fixture) controlled by a photocell and intended to illuminate the intersection at ground level rather than serve as a traffic signal. Staff said that traffic signal or roundabout warrants are not met at current volumes but that staff will evaluate future traffic increases and recommend appropriate measures if warrants are later met.
Applicant land planner Keith Nichter described clustering around washes, adding emergency and temporary construction access (restored to trail/emergency use after construction), and preserving larger NAOS tracts inside the subdivision. Nichter also said water and sewer infrastructure are stubbed to the site and that the project will pay in‑lieu fees for regional system improvements when required. The team committed to DRB photometric review and low‑level entry lighting to minimize impacts on the dark‑sky area.
Pam Stubbs, a longtime Scottsdale realtor, testified in favor of the project, saying it fits the area character and could appeal to buyers seeking larger lots.
Commissioner Drake moved to recommend approval per staff stipulations; Commissioner Hartel seconded. The motion passed by roll call 7–0. The recommendation will be forwarded to City Council for final action; DRB will handle detailed lighting, landscaping and final design review.
