Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Demolition 415 N Alfred topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
BAR approves permit to demolish 415 North Alfred after heated public review
Summary
The Alexandria Board of Architectural Review voted to approve a demolition permit for the one‑story building at 415 North Alfred and heard extensive public opposition to the developer’s concept for five replacement townhouses, with neighbors and preservation architects urging a redesign.
The Alexandria Board of Architectural Review on Wednesday approved a permit to demolish a non‑contributing one‑story structure at 415 North Alfred Street, clearing the way for a developer’s concept for five new townhouses despite strong neighborhood opposition.
The applicant, PT Bloomes Development, said the existing building had been altered repeatedly and that consultants concluded it was non‑contributing to the Old and Historic District. Patrick Bloomfield, the developer, described a design intent of five cohesive townhouses with a private courtyard and accessory units, and said the proposal would provide new family housing and private open space.
Neighbors and preservation professionals pressed the board for a different approach. Architect Wayne Neal, a former BAR member who said he has worked in Old Town for decades, asked the board a blunt question: “Is the proposed building compatible with the surrounding streetscape? And the answer is no,” and urged the developer to pursue individual townhouse designs that better reflect the block’s variety.
Other residents echoed concerns about massing and light impacts. Nathaniel Choate, a nearby property owner, warned that the proposal reads as a single, monolithic block and said the design fails to provide the variety residents expect of Old Town. Multiple speakers asked about demolition logistics and potential environmental contamination; one board speaker read out a question from a resident: “I assume there was a phase 1 study done, to analyze the soil and air.”
Board members acknowledged the public input and praised extensive neighborhood engagement but also noted that the permit to demolish must be judged on the existing structure’s historic status and compliance with criteria. After a motion, second and roll‑call, the BAR voted to approve the demolition permit by recorded vote.
The developer said they would continue to work with neighbors on design revisions; the board’s concept review feedback highlighted requests for greater facade variety, reduced perceived massing, more brick detailing and clearer treatment of rear access and alley impacts. A follow‑up BAR review was anticipated before any final certificate of appropriateness or building permits were issued.
