Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Water Main Break Insurance topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Bernard Street water-main break floods basement; insurer declines claim, city weighs precedent
Summary
A break in an 8-inch main on Bernard Street sent an estimated 10,000 gallons into a finished basement; remediation and restoration quotes total about $31,000. The city's insurer (referred to in the transcript as "Legit") declined coverage, prompting council discussion about whether the city should continue past practice of assisting homeowners or set a stricter future policy.
City staff informed the council about a significant water-main break on Bernard Street that allowed roughly an estimated 10,000 gallons of water into a finished basement. Staff provided two contractor estimates: remediation and mold mitigation at about $9,000 and full restoration at about $21,000, for a combined approximate total of $31,000.
Staff said Frostburg’s insurer (referred to in the transcript as "Legit") declined to cover the claim, asserting the break was not caused by city negligence. Staff described prior informal practice of the city assisting affected homeowners when similar incidents occurred, but noted the insurer’s refusal raised questions about precedent and budget exposure.
Councilors discussed options including limiting city payments in future to abatement only, establishing a formal policy, or continuing the past practice of financial assistance in certain cases. Staff said they will consult with the city attorney (Michael Cohen) and evaluate budget lines to determine how to absorb costs this time and whether to adopt a formal policy going forward.
Next steps: staff will work with the city attorney to draft a clearer policy for future incidents and will identify funding sources to cover the current remediation and restoration expenses; the figures presented are based on contractor quotes and staff estimates.
