Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Art 477 9th topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves tile-based public art for 477 9th Avenue amid debate over scale and visibility
Summary
The commission approved a $225,000 site-specific tile installation at 477 9th Avenue by a New York design duo; commissioners debated whether multiple two-story tile arches would read as building ornamentation rather than standalone art before passing the proposal 3–1.
The Civic Arts Commission approved a $225,000 public-art package for a five-story mixed-use building at 477 9th Avenue that uses printed and hand‑screened tiles to clad multiple entry archways.
The project consultant said the design wraps the building with site-specific tile on seven prominent archways—two larger entry arches and five two-story arches near resident and office entrances—and that the tiles are fabricated abroad to meet budget and durability requirements. “We went through an artist process … we ended up settling on a New York duo named Fayol,” the consultant said, describing the approach and noting the tiles are manufactured in Mexico and installed by a subcontractor to ensure longevity.
The proposal’s $225,000 art budget and the decision to distribute tile across seven touch points prompted extended debate among commissioners. One commissioner warned the work risked reading as ornament or building material rather than art and said, “If you ask somebody where’s the artwork on that, they can't give me an answer.” Another commissioner defended the multiple touch points as a way to activate different elevations and provide a human‑scale experience no matter which side of the building pedestrians approach.
The commission voted 3–1 to approve the tile installation; one commissioner recorded a negative vote. Staff noted the design responds to downtown objective design standards calling for Spanish Mediterranean materials and said plaques at each tile location are planned to identify the installation as public art.
Construction timing depends on façade completion; the consultant estimated a three- to four-month fabrication window after approval and said tile installation would be among the final items before building completion.
The vote concludes the commission’s review of the 477 9th Avenue art design and allows the project to proceed to fabrication and installation coordination with staff and the developer.
