Council asks county for justification before supporting Stark Street Bridge replacement

The Troutdale City Council debated a draft letter of support for federal funding to replace the historic Stark Street Bridge and voted to request additional justification from Multnomah County before sending any endorsement.

Council discussion ranged from preservation concerns — noting the bridge’s historic role on the Columbia River Highway and scenic value — to safety and operational concerns, including repeated damage from trucks and a reportedly temporary earlier repair. The mayor, speaking both as mayor and as a historical‑society representative, asked the county to provide a clear explanation of why replacement is necessary rather than continued repairs.

Several councilors argued the structure has been repeatedly damaged, carries weight restrictions, and can close unexpectedly, disrupting traffic. Others cautioned against replacing the bridge with an incongruous modern structure and urged careful design review to protect the area’s scenic and historic character.

A motion to ask the county for an informational package and justification passed by roll call (recorded Yes and No votes showed a divided council). Staff said the item will return after the county supplies the requested information, and the council will then reconsider whether to sign a letter of support for replacement funding.