Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Design Standards topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Builders press for flexibility in downtown architectural standards; city staff proposes objective adjustments
Summary
Local builders and an applicant representative urged the commission to relax prescriptive 'preferred' and 'prohibited' building‑material rules in parts of the city, saying strict masonry requirements can increase commercial building costs by an estimated 5–8%; staff said it will refine language and consider percent‑based standards or design‑review mechanisms.
Developers and city staff engaged in a detailed discussion about proposed ordinance language that would make preferred materials mandatory on Main Street and 200 North while prohibiting certain discouraged materials elsewhere.
"It's adding, give or take, 5 to 8% to the total cost of the building to, you know, full masonry," Tyler Melling said, arguing that prescriptive lists can make projects economically unfeasible in some locations. Melling and other developers asked that the ordinance allow newer composite materials that emulate preferred materials and that staff adopt clearer, objective criteria so administrative review is not overly subjective.
City staff acknowledged the goal of protecting downtown character but said the ordinance could be refined to reduce subjectivity—options discussed included percentage limits for materials, allowing architectural veneers or modern ACM (aluminum composite material) panels in limited application, and creating a design‑review body for tougher architectural judgments. Staff and the applicant said they will continue refining the language and present a more complete proposal at next week's re‑noticed meeting.
Commissioners emphasized the importance of preserving downtown architectural quality while also avoiding requirements that stifle development or raise project costs unnecessarily. No final ordinance action was taken tonight; the item will be re‑noticed for a future hearing.
