Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Proviso Process topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate Ways and Means narrows late provisos, votes to return policy provisos to committee
Summary
After a lengthy procedural debate, the Senate Ways and Means Committee voted to return policy-related provisos to standing committees for fuller vetting and recommended attaching a staff-prepared financial note to future provisos. The change aims to separate dollar changes from policy changes and improve transparency.
Senate Ways and Means members voted to send policy-related provisos back to the committees that oversee those subjects for fuller consideration, after a daylong debate over whether last-minute provisos should be handled in this committee.
The committee’s move followed a substitute motion to return a STAR bond proviso to the Commerce committee for proponent and opponent hearings. Senator Klim said the matter ‘‘should be in a committee where it gets a robust conversation’’ and moved to send it back; the substitute motion was seconded and carried. Senator Erickson, who originally brought the STAR bond clarification, said the intent of her language was to avoid changing rules for projects already underway and to apply new constraints only to future projects.
Why it matters: members framed the decision as a transparency and process fix. Senator Alley urged that ‘‘if you bring a proviso, you have a financial note attached to that proviso that says this is what it cost’’ so the committee can see the fiscal impact. The committee adopted an amendment from the motion’s maker limiting the return requirement to provisos that change policy; members stressed financial provisos that only add dollars may be treated differently.
Committee staff explained next steps and timing. Senator Owens and others asked authors to submit written language and financial notes ahead of the committee’s next meeting so staff and members can review proposals in writing rather than by oral motion. The maker agreed to refile several ideas in writing for the next session.
The action will change how late provisos are handled for the remainder of the budget process: substantive policy changes now must be vetted in the subject committee before inclusion in the Ways and Means package, and future provisos should include a staff-prepared cost estimate to clarify fiscal consequences.
The committee recessed for caucus and said it will reconvene to consider the written proviso language and remaining budget business.
