House rejects repeal of childhood immunization requirements after contentious public-health debate
Loading...
Summary
The House debated HB 18-11, which would repeal statutory school immunization requirements, with supporters emphasizing parental choice and opponents warning of disease resurgence; the motion to pass the bill failed on a roll-call vote (155–192).
The New Hampshire House on Feb. 12 considered House Bill 18-11, a proposal to repeal statutory childhood immunization requirements for school attendance. After extended floor discussion and a roll-call vote, the bill failed.
Supporters framed HB 18-11 as restoring parental choice and ‘‘informed consent.’’ Representative Potenza argued mandates should not overrule individual medical decisions and urged colleagues to "press the green button and support the committee's recommendation." Representative Wayne McDonald and others described the proposal as consistent with recent pro-family measures.
Opponents, including public health defenders who addressed the chamber, said repeal would reduce vaccination coverage and risk outbreaks. Representative Lamont Sands warned that "declining vaccination rates around the country have led to diseases we once had under control to come back," citing measles and other vaccine-preventable diseases; he told the House that expert testimony and medical associations opposed repeal. Representative Drew, speaking for the committee, reiterated that HB 18-11 "is not a ban on vaccines" but removes statutory mandates and highlighted concerns about vaccine safety claims from supporters.
After debate and parliamentary inquiries about safety data, fiscal notes, and the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, the House held a roll-call on the 'ought to pass' motion. The motion to pass HB 18-11 failed with 155 voting in the affirmative and 192 in the negative.
What’s next: With the motion defeated on the floor, HB 18-11 did not advance to enactment during the Feb. 12 session. Further action would require reconsideration or reintroduction in a future session period.
Quotes in this article come directly from on‑the‑record floor remarks by Representatives Potenza, Lamont Sands and Drew as recorded in the Feb. 12 session.
