Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Litigation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission says Clayton Mines appeal could force CMP rewrite; case is pending
Summary
Commission staff reported the Clayton Mines appeal challenges CMP provisions on nonconsumptive water use; briefing is complete and an appellate decision could invalidate parts of the rules and require revisions, staff said. Separately, an AG‑filed ‘artistic materials’ enforcement case is entering discovery with DEP joining the commission.
Commission legal staff updated members on two active cases that could shape future Pinelands policy.
Stacy reported the Clayton Mines appeal challenges language in the Comprehensive Management Plan (CMP) that governs nonconsumptive water use; the company argues the relevant provision is vague. Briefing has been completed and the commission is still awaiting word from the court on whether there will be oral argument or a straight decision. Stacy said that if the appellate division were to agree with Clayton on key points, affected CMP rules could be invalidated and would likely have to be returned to the commission for revision.
Stacy also briefed the commission on litigation the commission initiated involving so‑called "artistic materials," noting the Attorney General's office filed the complaint on Jan. 2 and that the case has held its first case management conference and is about to enter discovery. Stacy said the Department of Environmental Protection has joined the commission in that enforcement action.
Commissioners asked for clarification about the Clayton matter during public comment; staff committed to provide further context as decisions develop. The meeting record contains no court timetable beyond staff noting they have been waiting for a decision since January.
