Hoboken told to repay $332,345 in FEMA/NJOEM COVID overpayment; city contested most of it
Loading...
Summary
City staff told council NJOEM has demanded repayment of $332,345 after a post‑closeout eligibility reversal; the city says it contested roughly $250,000 in fire overtime costs but FEMA denied those appeals; council asked whether legal action or a multi‑municipal challenge is feasible.
City Director Gonzalez informed the council that New Jersey Office of Emergency Management, which administers FEMA distribution in the state, has notified Hoboken of a $332,345 overpayment related to a COVID‑19 Project Worksheet closeout. The city and its grant‑writing firm appealed but FEMA (through NJOEM) reversed eligibility on part of the amount and required repayment. "In November 2025, NJOEM notified the city of a 332,345 overpayment related to a COVID‑nineteen project worksheet..." the director reported.
Director Gonzalez said the city strongly contested roughly $250,000 of the amount, which was specific to fire department overtime costs, but the appeals were unsuccessful. The director warned the council that failure to repay could lead to suspension or withholding of other FEMA disbursements. Councilmembers asked whether the city had legal grounds to sue; the director said the city exhausted the administrative appeals available and was uncertain about legal grounds for litigation. Several members proposed coordinating with other affected municipalities to share costs and legal strategy if the issue is widespread.
Councilmembers asked staff to produce and distribute the grant‑administration firm's memo that documents the appeal and the city's position. "If this is happening across the board, then we're all in this together," one councilmember said, urging a coalition approach. The administration said it would provide a detailed memo to the council and investigate whether coordinated action is feasible.
No final repayment decision was recorded at the meeting; council directed staff to share the underlying documentation and continue evaluating appeal and litigation options.
