FERC votes to remove Western bilateral spot-market soft price cap, cites expanded enforcement tools
Loading...
Summary
At its February open meeting, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission voted unanimously on the consent agenda that included rescinding the Western Electricity Coordinating Council'area bilateral spot-market soft price cap, saying modern surveillance and enforcement tools now provide stronger protections for consumers.
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission approved a consent agenda in its February open meeting that included an order removing a long-standing soft price cap on bilateral spot sales in the Western Electricity Coordinating Council footprint.
Chairman Sweatt framed the change as part of a broader move to adapt market oversight to current conditions. He told colleagues that PJM reforms and other market measures affecting tens of millions of customers remain a priority and that "we are ready to quickly evaluate your proposals or take other action if necessary." The chair listed E2'the WEC soft-cap rescission'among the items the commission planned to act on during the meeting.
The commission and staff said the rescission responds to a D.C. Circuit decision that changed how Mobile Sierra principles apply to bilateral contracts, and that the cap, first adopted after the 2001'2002 California energy crisis, no longer serves the same function. Multiple commissioners argued that enforcement capacity and market monitoring have matured since 2002. Commissioner Lacerte said the cap is "a relic of the California energy crisis" and that modern, regional market constructs and enforcement authority make the cap unnecessary. Commissioner Chang acknowledged concerns raised in docket comments about eliminating the cap but concurred with the order given the commission's expanded oversight tools.
Staff from the Office of Enforcement (DAS) presented the surveillance capabilities that underlie the commission's confidence in removing the soft cap. DAS staff described continuous access to trade data for major Western hubs on the Intercontinental Exchange, a memorandum of understanding with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission that provides next-day large-trader report data, the commission's Order No. 760 data feeds from organized markets, e-tag transmission scheduling data, and the Electric Quarterly Report (EQR) for ex post reviews. Presenters said these data sources feed dynamic dashboards and algorithmic screens that flag anomalous trades, circular scheduling, or other patterns that might signal market manipulation.
DAS described both real-time surveillance and quarterly ex post analysis. An enforcement presenter said staff can "conduct enhanced surveillance" during extreme events, request supplemental data, coordinate with RTO monitoring units and other agencies, and refer matters to the Division of Investigations where appropriate. Ex post work uses EQR and public data to benchmark bilateral prices, evaluate liquidity and deliverability, and, when necessary, conduct deep dives on particular sellers or transactions.
The commission voted on the consent agenda by roll call; each commissioner recorded an "aye" vote, approving E1'E10, G1'G3, H1'H4, and C1'C2. The record notes concurring separate statements for several hydro categorical-exclusion actions.
The order rescinding the WEC soft price cap takes effect as specified in the final order. Commissioners and staff stressed that rescinding the cap does not leave consumers unprotected: enforcement authority (including penalty authority provided by Congress) and enhanced data feeds and screens are central to the commission's oversight strategy.
Next steps: the commission placed the rescission order on the record as part of the consent vote; staff and the Office of Enforcement will continue to coordinate with RTOs and market monitors as EDAM, RTO West and Markets Plus move forward.
