Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Use Signs topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Sunny Isles Beach staff recommends replacing political-sign rule with neutral temporary-sign standards
Summary
City staff told commissioners their current ordinance singling out political signs is unenforceable after recent court decisions and proposed folding temporary-sign rules into the land-development code with uniform size, location and time limits by zoning district.
City of Sunny Isles Beach staff told commissioners at a June workshop that the city—ode section regulating political signs is no longer enforceable under recent court precedent and recommended replacing it with neutral, zoning-based rules for temporary signage.
The city ttorney said the existing chapter 2-27 treats political signs differently from other signs and is therefore vulnerable after the U.S. Supreme Court nd federal appeals rulings that prohibit subject-matter discrimination in sign regulation. "You have to treat them all in a classification that's neutral," staff said, recommending repeal of 2-27 and incorporation of temporary-sign controls into the land development regulations.
Under staff's draft approach, single-family yards would be limited to two temporary signs, with a maximum sign face of about 4.5 square feet (top of sign 3 feet from grade); commercial and multi-family zoning districts would also be limited to two signs but allow larger dimensions (staff cited an 8-square-foot, 6-foot-from-grade example for several commercial zones). Time limits were discussed as a way to keep signs truly temporary; staff initially proposed a 90-day limit and later suggested 120 days or an annual-total approach to address campaign and recurring noncommercial signs.
Commissioners pressed staff on enforcement logistics and unintended consequences, including whether residents or property owners would be held responsible if a tenant or campaign placed signs on private property. Staff said enforcement would be complaint-driven and focused on the property owner consistent with existing signage rules. The city attorney warned that narrow content-based rules remain unlawful and that any new ordinance should be content-neutral but may regulate size, location, number and time.
What happens next: staff will draft a formal ordinance for the commission nd return with line-by-line language for further review and possible readings.
