Clintondale board ratifies three‑year teachers’ contract after debate over process
Loading...
Summary
After debate over whether to go into closed session, the Clintondale Community Schools Board unanimously ratified a three‑year contract with the teachers’ association, ending a roughly 500‑day impasse and prompting public thanks from classroom teachers.
The Clintondale Community Schools Board of Education voted unanimously to ratify a three‑year contract with the teachers’ association, approving the 2025–2028 CEA agreement by a 7–0 roll‑call vote.
The vote followed an extended and sometimes tense discussion about procedure and transparency. Treasurer Powers moved to take the matter into a closed session, citing the Open Meetings Act’s negotiation exemption and saying the matter involved roughly $2,000,000 in payroll. Powers said he had not seen the contract in time to provide informed oversight and argued members needed an executive summary and time to review the document. "It's disrespectful and it's an insult to my intelligence to ask me to approve a contract that I haven't read," Powers said.
Colleagues offered differing views on how to proceed. Several trustees said they understood Powers' concerns and the need for clarity, while others urged keeping the discussion public and moving to ratify the agreement promptly to give teachers stability after a long delay. Vice President Lisa Valerio Nook said she had conferred with the superintendent before the meeting and was comfortable proceeding either in a short closed session or in public if members were satisfied. At the chair's direction the board took a short recess for members to consult; after the break Powers withdrew his motion to go into closed session, saying he had the opportunity to digest the materials and no longer intended to press the motion.
Chair President Maynard and the superintendent summarized the contract’s principal terms on the record. The chair characterized the agreement as a district‑centered solution reached with the bargaining team; the superintendent described the deal as a three‑year agreement and said language required by Public Act 54 remained in the contract. The superintendent also highlighted commonly renegotiated elements — salary schedules (lanes and steps), release time and special‑education language — and said similar negotiation pressures were affecting districts across Michigan.
Board members praised the bargaining teams and urged finalizing the agreement so teachers could return to classroom stability after roughly 500 days without a settled contract. The clerk then called the roll and the board approved the contract unanimously.
During the non‑agenda public‑comment period, kindergarten teacher Dawn Durkaz told the board she had seen teachers "cry tears of joy" when presented with the contract documents and said many staff members expected they would not need to take a second job if the agreement stood.
The chair closed by noting the board's action and the meeting adjourned at 8:20 p.m. The ratification completes the board's final step in approving the negotiated agreement; the union had already ratified the tentative agreement before the board vote.
