Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Comment And Accountability topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Residents press Carmichaels Area SD on program cuts, livestream privacy and layoffs
Summary
Multiple community members urged the board to preserve electives and extracurriculars, change livestreamed meeting speaker-identification practices, and reconsider recent layoffs. A former employee and long-time resident called for clearer accountability and transparency on spending and staffing decisions.
Several residents used the public-comment portion of the July 18 board meeting to press the district on program cuts, livestreamed meeting privacy and recent layoffs.
Longtime educator and parent Mister Bates told the board he was "proud to be a Mike" and warned that programs once commonplace — elementary art, library science, metal shop, woodshop, home economics and some advanced courses — are disappearing from the district. "We're losing many of the valuable opportunities for our students," Bates said, urging the board to keep a comprehensive curriculum that serves the "whole child." The board president responded that the members at the table shared his concern.
Diane Smith, a Carmichaels resident, asked the board to stop requiring speakers to state a full street address on livestreamed meetings and suggested a safer alternative: show ID privately to a board member off camera. "Sharing that information with a small group of members and attendees is not a big deal, but shouting it out online is a different matter," Smith said, and asked the board to consider changing the rule.
Former district employee Amy Eddy said she was laid off on June 30 for "economic hardship" and asked the board to consider rehiring staff and finding a budget plan to bring people back. "I love this school district," Eddy said, and asked the board to "figure out a way to bring us back." Board members acknowledged the comments and one suggested a compromise on the livestream procedure during the meeting.
Speakers also raised questions about the lifecycle and replacement frequency of Chromebooks versus textbooks and the effect of unrestricted cellphone use in classrooms. Smith cited research and a book she called "Digital Cocaine" to argue prolonged smartphone access can harm students' attention and wellbeing.
The board did not take immediate policy action on the comments but directed staff to consider procedural alternatives for verifying residency without publicly broadcasting addresses. Members also signaled awareness of program and staffing pressures as they proceeded through the fiscal and personnel agenda items.
