Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Title Ix topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board rejects bid to rescind Granville's 2024 Title IX rules after heated debate
Summary
Board members rejected a motion to rescind the district's August 5, 2024 Title IX rules and revert to the 2020 policy after a divided debate and roll-call vote. Proponents cited community concerns; opponents warned rescinding would expose the district to legal action under federal law.
The Granville Board of Education voted down a motion to rescind the district's 2024 Title IX rules, following more than an hour of debate and public comment on Oct. 14.
Board member (speaker S10) moved to rescind the rules adopted Aug. 5 and restore the 2020 policy; the motion was seconded by another board member (S9). Supporters of rescission argued the newer rules had become politically charged in the community and cited pending litigation around Title IX implementation. "It would bring the lever down," one supporter said, urging the board to "reset" to the earlier policy.
Opponents including the superintendent (S2) urged the board to maintain compliance with federal law. The superintendent said the 2024 policy is "policy based upon federal law" and cautioned that failing to follow the regulations would likely lead to lawsuits and financial damages. "If we did not pass it, the exposure would have so many detrimental effects on the district we all love," he said.
After discussion and a public-comment period during which speakers voiced sharply differing views, the board took a roll-call vote. The clerk read votes aloud: Winertjem — Yes; Klein — No; Stuckus — Yes; Gardine — No; Palmer — No; DeHaan — Yes; Highbore — No. With three yes votes and four no votes, the motion failed.
Nut graf: The vote preserves the district's existing Title IX rules as of Aug. 5. Supporters of rescission said the change would align policy with community preferences and pending legal developments; opponents said federal-law compliance and legal risk counsel keeping the 2024 rules in place.
Board members debated whether the 2024 changes materially altered school practices around bathrooms, locker rooms, pronouns and athletics. The superintendent told the board that the regulations "do not change what we do and have done with a high level of success" and that the Michigan High School Athletic Association remains the governing body for sport eligibility. Several board members said they prefer letting courts resolve unsettled legal questions rather than exposing the district to potential losses.
Public comment at the meeting was intense: some parents and community members urged the board to rescind, citing concerns about privacy and girls' sports; others defended the district's inclusive practices and said rescinding would harm students.
What happens next: The district will retain the August 5, 2024 Title IX rules while litigation and state-level actions proceed. Several public speakers urged clearer communications from the district about how Title IX processes are applied and what internal safeguards are in place.
