Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Streetscape Fencing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Developer seeks limited front-yard fences in Renn Quarter; neighbors and staff urge caution
Summary
Ren Quarter developer asked the Planning Commission to permit front-yard fences for rear-load townhomes; the developer agreed to staff'recommended 36-inch limit but neighbors and staff warned fences could undermine a pedestrian-friendly streetscape and raise maintenance and precedent concerns.
Kara McJunkin, general partner of Ren Quarter TH LLC, asked the City of Frederick Planning Commission on Feb. 17 to allow front-yard fences for rear-load integral townhomes in Renn Quarter Phase 3. McJunkin said the developer initially sought 48-inch open-slat black aluminum fences but agreed the commission's staff recommendation to limit fences to 36 inches.
McJunkin told the commission the fences are intended to "define property lines, enhance curb appeal, and foster community interaction," and said the fences have performed well in other projects the applicant developed. She said rental property management would enforce lease restrictions and maintain landscaping, and that synthetic turf and low-maintenance plantings are planned for the narrow front yards.
Staff recommended limiting the allowed lots and the fence height to 36 inches, saying the city favors open front yards to support pedestrian connectivity in mixed-use (MU) zones and that broad allowance could create an undesirable precedent. "We do believe in open front yards," a staff presenter said, and noted the city's fence ordinance and processes for individual exceptions through the Zoning Board of Appeals.
Heather Goddard of East Frederick Rising, speaking during public comment, urged the commission not to allow front-yard fencing across an MU neighborhood. She said Monroe Avenue will have a planned shared-use path and that front-yard fences "may discourage a pedestrian-friendly streetscape" and create visual clutter if enforcement is inconsistent.
Commissioners asked about maintenance responsibilities, the size of the front yards (applicant said townhome widths are about 20 feet with a minimum 15-foot depth), and whether fences would be stepped or undulated to avoid long, monotonous lines along the sidewalk. McJunkin said property management will be responsible for upkeep and that the developer's standard approach includes plant beds and synthetic turf to reduce maintenance impacts.
The commission did not vote on a change at the workshop; McJunkin said she would provide additional renderings of open-space areas and return for the formal hearing. The staff report recommended approval only for selected lots and with a 36-inch height limit.
