Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Municipal Claims topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Claims committee recommends denial for Cobble Hill damage, approves 50% payout for Whipple Road claim
Summary
The claims committee reviewed two vehicle-damage claims: it recommended denying a $303.31 claim for damage at 144 Cobble Hill after DPW said the recessed catch basin was by design, and recommended a 50% payout ($555.91) on a $1,111.82 Whipple Road claim; both recommendations were approved by vocal assent.
The claims committee reviewed two vehicle-damage claims and recorded two recommendations: a denial for a Cobble Hill claim and a split payment for a Whipple Road claim.
At the start of the meeting the chair noted two claims on the agenda and the committee approved the previous meeting’s minutes by voice vote. The committee then took up a claim alleging a vehicle struck a sunken drainage catch basin in front of 144 Cobble Hill, reporting about $303.31 in damage to the vehicle’s muffler and other parts. A committee member cited a memo from the Department of Public Works (DPW) that the catch basin elevation is intentionally set to prevent driveway flooding and that the basin sits on a curve; the DPW reported this was the first notice of any problem at that location.
A staff member said the absence of prior complaints undercuts the town’s notice of a hazard and noted the basin appears recessed by design. After discussion, the committee recorded a motion, documented in the meeting as moved by Councilman Shep and seconded by Councilman Madesau, to recommend the council deny the Cobble Hill claim; the committee approved the recommendation by vocal assent.
The committee then discussed a second claim from Whipple Road, where a vehicle reportedly hit a large pothole hidden by standing water and sought $1,111.82 in repairs. Members reviewed DPW’s note that it received first notice of the pothole and that the area was repaired; committee members also described the road in the provided photos as rough. One committee member moved to recommend a 50% payout on the claim. The committee calculated the payment at $555.91 and, with the motion recorded as moved by Councilman Muscat and seconded by Councilman Hayes, approved the recommendation by vocal assent.
There was no public comment either in the room or online. The committee then moved to adjourn and ended the session.
Votes at a glance • Cobble Hill (144 Cobble Hill): motion to recommend denial; mover recorded as Councilman Shep; second recorded as Councilman Madesau; committee recorded vocal approval. • Whipple Road (pothole): motion to recommend 50% payout ($555.91) on a $1,111.82 claim; mover recorded as Councilman Muscat; second recorded as Councilman Hayes; committee recorded vocal approval.
What this means These committee actions are recommendations to the council; the full council must still act to finalize any payment or denial. DPW’s written notifications and the committee’s comments that each issue was a "first notice" factored into the committee’s reasoning.
