Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Hospital Closure topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Hudson County commissioners agree to legal review after call to protect Christ Hospital; county counsel to vet language before Thursday agenda
Summary
Commissioner William O'Dea asked the Hudson County Board to place a resolution on the Thursday agenda demanding transparency and a financial safety net if Christ/Hudson Regional Health seeks to close; County Counsel said the language will be reviewed and the item circulated to commissioners before any formal vote.
Commissioner William O'Dea asked the Hudson County Board of County Commissioners on Oct. 7 to place a draft resolution on the public agenda seeking protections for Christ Hospital (operated as Hudson Regional Health) and a financial safety net for the county’s safety-net hospitals.
O'Dea read a draft that cited 2023 service volumes — "over 12,000 inpatient procedures and over 70,000 emergency room visits" — and said the county and state should pursue resources, require a clear written closure plan, and consider a pilot 'health-care tax' to help offset charity care. "This is related to Christ Hospital, a hospital that may close," he said, urging the Board to engage with District 1199-J and hospital unions.
The request prompted immediate procedural and policy pushback. County Executive (identified in the record as "County Executive Guy") protested a rhetorical comparison O'Dea made to a prior administration, saying it was inappropriate; O'Dea apologized and framed his comments as a procedural historical reference. Board Counsel Carmen Mendiola said she had not received the email draft; County Counsel Alberico DePierro said the law office needed time to review and to ensure any resolution is legally sufficient before it is put to a vote.
Why it matters: the draft frames a hospital closure as a public-safety and economic issue, citing potential job losses ("over 1,000 healthcare . . . jobs" mentioned in the draft) and local impacts on ER access and wait times. O'Dea and union representatives argued for quick action; several commissioners urged a more deliberate process, requesting written materials and legal review before the Board considers policy commitments that could carry fiscal or legal consequences.
Board next steps: County Counsel said he would review the language and requested circulating a revised draft to commissioners. Chairman Anthony Romano asked unions and hospital stakeholders to provide the Board with clear documentation and asked the Administration to verify reported facts so the Board can move in an informed way. No formal vote on the draft resolution occurred at the caucus; the item was slated for further review and a possible appearance on the Thursday public agenda once counsel completes its review.
Direct quotes from the meeting capture the split over speed and process. O'Dea said, "This is related to Christ Hospital, a hospital that may close, a hospital where I was born." County Executive Guy replied sharply, "Commissioner, shame on you for comparing this administration to the previous administration Bob Januszewski, who went to jail for ethical and criminal problems." County Counsel told commissioners the office needed the draft and time to vet it. The Chair and multiple commissioners asked that unions and the Administration share documentation prior to the Thursday meeting.
The Board did not adopt the draft resolution on Tuesday. The next procedural step is a legal sufficiency review by County Counsel and circulation of any revised language to commissioners prior to the Thursday agenda.
