Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Youth Shelter Contracts topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commissioners ask for outcome data on youth-shelter contract amid questions about tracking
Summary
The board reviewed a $161,330 contract with the YMCA to operate youth shelter beds and pressed staff for counts of days with more than two beds in use, average length of stay, and long-term outcomes. County staff said some data exist but long-term tracking is limited and the State has discouraged tracking juveniles beyond certain points.
During the Nov. 24 caucus Hudson County commissioners reviewed a one-year contract with the Young Men's Christian Association (YMCA) to operate youth shelter services for county youth in need of shelter.
The clerk read the contract terms, including a per-day rate that the commissioners discussed. Commissioner William O'Dea pressed for operational metrics: "How many days did we do three beds? How many days did we do four beds? I would just be curious to know that," he said, and also asked for average length of stay and post-shelter outcomes, including education and employment status for prior participants.
Darice Toon, Director of Health and Human Services, described the contract scope—meals, tutoring, counseling, life-skills and vocational activities—and said the $161,330 contract offsets program costs but does not fully cover them. Toon said that some interns or participants have been hired by host sites and that site partners include hospitals and educational partners; she pledged to obtain available data on bed usage and length-of-stay. On long-term outcome tracking, she told the board that the State had expressed concerns about collecting longitudinal juvenile data in prior conversations: "They indicated that that goes against their policy," Toon said, noting she would consult with the judge and the State to determine what follow-up data are available.
Why it matters: Commissioners framed the request as oversight—if the county funds shelter beds and wraparound services, the board wants evidence of impact (placement, school completion, recidivism). O'Dea urged the board to compile multi-year results where possible and said the county should ensure investments produce lasting benefits for young people rather than only short-term shelter.
Next steps: County staff committed to returning with available bed-usage counts (days with three or four beds), average length of stay, and whatever outcome tracking exists. The caucus did not adopt the contract formally; it will be placed on the regular meeting agenda for a vote.
