Clemency board recommends denying commutation for Jeremy Myers after family testimony

The Washington State Clemency and Pardons Board voted unanimously March 13 to recommend denial of Jeremy Myers’ request for commutation, following a day of testimony from the petitioner, the prosecuting attorney and multiple members of the victim’s family.

Myers, who said in his presentation "I am so sorry that I murdered Jessica," spent his allotted time describing personal shame, prison programs and efforts at rehabilitation. He also made statements that board members characterized as contradictory: at times Myers said he was not present when Jessica died while also telling the panel, "I am the one that murdered Jessica," a distinction that prompted follow-up questioning about the factual record and his credibility.

Why it matters: Prosecutor Richard Weyrich urged the board to defer to the trial record and appellate rulings, saying the jury found Myers guilty of first-degree murder and appeals were exhausted. Multiple family members — including Jessica’s mother and cousins — told the board they oppose any reduction in sentence and described fear for their safety if Myers were released. "Jeremy took my sister from me. I don't forgive him," said a family member who used only her first name, Nikki.

Board members repeatedly pressed Myers on rehabilitative programming and the specifics of his claims. Aline Flower and other members said they were unconvinced that Myers had taken responsibility in a way that met the board’s standard for commutation. Flower told Myers the record — including an appellate decision describing "overwhelming evidence" — must be respected.

The motion to recommend denial was made by Board Member Rhonda Salveson and seconded by Vice Chair Doug Baldwin Jr.; the board voted 5–0 to carry the motion. Chair Raymond Delos Reyes reminded all parties that the board’s recommendation is advisory and that the governor has final authority.

What the board cited: victim impact testimony describing ongoing trauma and safety concerns; the jury verdict and appellate history; counsel’s representation that direct appeals were completed; and what members described as inconsistency in Myers’ statements during his appearance.

Next steps: The board’s recommendation will be sent to the governor for a final decision. The recommendation does not change Myers’ sentence unless the governor acts.