Citizen Portal
Sign In

Lifetime Citizen Portal Access — AI Briefings, Alerts & Unlimited Follows

HARB approves emergency removal and CMU reconstruction for collapsing wall at 7 Aviles Street

City of St. Augustine Historic Architecture Review Board · February 19, 2026

Loading...

AI-Generated Content: All content on this page was generated by AI to highlight key points from the meeting. For complete details and context, we recommend watching the full video. so we can fix them.

Summary

The board approved demolition of a failing south wall at 7 Aviles Street, finding rot and termite damage created an emergency; it required the reconstructed wall to have a washed joint/smooth finish and be painted to match existing stucco using an approved finish.

The Historic Architecture Review Board on Feb. 19 approved an emergency demolition and reconstruction at 7 Aviles Street after staff and the applicant presented evidence that the south wall is deteriorated, with termite and rot damage and a risk of collapse. Applicant Chad Swaniger and consulting architect Frank Ringhofer described the wall as a wood-frame/stucco assembly with crumbling lath and structural failure, and staff recommended either approval or continuance pending material verification.

Board members and visiting contractors agreed the wall posed a safety hazard and recommended prompt action. The board voted to allow demolition and reconstruction in concrete masonry unit (CMU) block with a floated/washed joint to approximate stucco texture and to paint the wall with a mineral-based (Kyme/Keim-style) finish to match the existing colors; any existing window openings must be maintained. The applicant and architect described construction constraints (8 inches between buildings) and discussed practical approaches (floating joints, acrylic/textured coatings) for achieving a compatible finish.

Why it matters: The board treated the proposal as an emergency demolition given imminent structural failure and safety risks to adjacent properties; the conditions require the reconstructed wall to visually match the existing stucco finish where visible.