Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Tree Removal Development topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning board approves limited tree removals in Madeira Phase 3 amid resident concern
Summary
Toll Brothers won board approval to remove trees on seven contracted lots in the Madeira subdivision after presenting an arborist inventory and site plans showing net preservation; neighbors warned about flooding, habitat loss and long‑term impacts.
The Planning & Zoning Board approved requests from builder Toll Brothers to remove certain significant trees on seven lots in Phase 3 of the Madeira subdivision, concluding a lengthy public discussion over conservation, drainage and construction impacts.
Toll Brothers representatives said they had narrowed an earlier submittal (which had proposed removal across many more lots) to only those lots that are under contract and ready for construction. The applicant presented an arborist inventory and per‑lot exhibits showing retained versus removed trees and emphasized stem‑wall construction and grading that avoids importing fill outside the toe of stem walls. The applicant said the net effect across the seven lots was a preservation gain — more tree inches retained than removed — and that every effort had been made to position buildings to minimize impacts to the largest specimens.
Neighbors raised three recurring concerns: potential increased flooding and altered drainage patterns if trees and canopy are removed; loss of wildlife habitat and bird roosting areas near the retention ponds; and longer‑term tree health after construction where canopies and root zones remain close to new foundations. Speakers submitted photos and described recent high tides and observed ponding in adjacent areas.
Board members pressed the applicant on tree health assessments, the arborist report methodology and the subdivision’s permitted grading and stormwater plans. Staff and the applicant explained that the subdivision has an approved permit from the St. Johns River Water Management District, that ponding and grading were addressed in the engineered site plans, and that as‑built certifications and permitting remain required as the homes are constructed.
Following discussion, the board approved the limited tree‑removal request for the seven identified lots, noting the applicant’s measures to retain larger trees where feasible and acknowledging the possibility that subsequent construction details could require the applicant to return for additional approvals if otherwise protected trees become hazardous or unviable.
