House approves tax change tied to heated tobacco products after floor debate over harm reduction
Loading...
Summary
The House approved Senate Bill 680, a measure tied to incentives for lower‑harm tobacco products. Sponsor Rep. Caldwell Trey argued the bill would encourage smokers to switch and cited international examples; colleagues pressed concerns about youth uptake and revenue losses. The bill passed on a recorded vote.
Representative Caldwell Trey presented Senate Bill 680 as a revenue/tobacco measure intended to encourage companies producing noncombustible heated tobacco products to come to Oklahoma and, in his view, reduce cigarette use. Caldwell said studies from other countries showed large reductions in cigarette use after similar product shifts, saying, "when a product similar to the products is these these heated products... we saw 4000000 peoples quit 4000000 people quit smoking cigarettes."
Opponents pressed for evidence and asked about potential impacts on young people and state revenues. Representative McCain and others sought specific study citations and asked whether cheaper alternative products could lead to initiation among youth. Caldwell acknowledged he did not have all specific numbers on hand and said some of the comparisons were anecdotal, but argued the net public‑health effect could be positive and that suppliers’ costs might make the new products less attractive to minors.
Representative Blancet asked about revenue trade‑offs; Caldwell responded that a healthier state with fewer smoking‑related illnesses would reduce long‑term costs and he said he would seek data on youth‑use effects. Several members raised concerns that the reduced excise tax on the alternative product could lower short‑term tax intake.
On the final recorded vote the House approved the bill; the clerk announced the tally as 52 aye and 38 nay. The bill will proceed to the next legislative steps for enrollment and transmittal.
