Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Neighborhood Infrastructure topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Residents of Josie Ranch urge Carrollton to repair crumbling perimeter walls, say voluntary HOA cannot cover costs
Summary
Multiple Josie Ranch residents told council that perimeter walls damaged by vehicle collisions and decades of wear are unsafe and unaffordable for their voluntary homeowners association; residents urged the city to assume repair responsibility or provide funding.
Several residents from the Josie Ranch neighborhood used the public forum to press the City Council for help repairing crumbling perimeter walls and addressing safety concerns they say have gone unresolved for years.
"Mandatory HOAs own their common areas and can get insurance; voluntary associations like ours cannot," said Heather Ashwell Hare, identifying herself as a resident of Savoy of Josie Ranch. She described the limitations of voluntary associations, volunteer-run finances and the inability to obtain liability insurance for common-area walls.
Doug Becker, a neighborhood volunteer, said the association collects about $9,600 a year in dues and spends roughly $7,000 annually on landscaping. He said vehicle strikes repeatedly damage the perimeter wall and that shifting responsibility to individual homeowners to maintain the wall to the street is impractical. "It's almost unrealistic for the homeowner to take responsibility... all the way to the street," Becker said.
Perla Canales described an ice-storm crash that flattened part of a brick wall behind her alley and said the city responded to clear debris but no police report or insurance claim followed. Pat Cochran, a former council member, warned council that the road design and repeated vehicle impacts make the sidewalk and wall a public-safety risk: "Someone will die," Cochran said, urging a durable solution.
Crystal Walker, president of the neighborhood association, said the wall replacement is a one-time capital expense that the voluntary association cannot afford and requested city action on a resolution discussed with redevelopment staff. Council indicated staff would follow up; the mayor directed staff to reach back out to residents for additional information and next steps.
Clarifying details presented during testimony included the neighborhood's limited dues revenue, lack of insurance for the wall, examples of recent collisions and residents' estimate that full wall replacement could be a six-figure capital cost.
The council did not take formal action on the public comments at the meeting, but staff committed to follow up with residents.
