Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Dispatch Outsourcing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Chief warns outsourcing dispatch would reduce local control; council weighs $160,000 startup and modest annual savings
Summary
Police Chief told the council that outsourcing the township dispatch center would sacrifice local knowledge and delay assistance; the administration’s cost analysis showed roughly $160,000 in one-time startup costs and estimated recurring savings of about $40,000–$45,000 per year, making payback several years — council members debated operational tradeoffs and staffing implications.
A detailed budget discussion on March 23 centered on the Washington Township Police Department, with extended debate over whether to outsource the local dispatch center.
Police Chief (recorded speaker) presented findings and cautioned that outsourcing — with options identified as Bergen County Division of Communications or Northwest Bergen Central Dispatch — would diminish local control, risk longer response or in-person assistance delays at the police lobby during off‑hours, and remove an in‑house capability to monitor school and municipal cameras. The chief emphasized that current in‑house dispatchers are residents or former officers who provide institutional knowledge that helps officers operate more efficiently.
Township Administrator Mark DeCarlo presented an Excel-based cost comparison the administration had prepared. He said the transition would require roughly $160,000 in one‑time startup costs (video and phone upgrades, building retrofits and upfront fees) but would produce recurring annual savings in the range of $40,000–$45,000 once recurring county contract fees and a potential receptionist/desk staffer were included. That profile would require multiple years to reach net savings.
Council members debated the tradeoffs. Supporters of evaluating outsourcing framed it as fiscally responsible to examine potential ongoing savings; opponents warned about degraded service, loss of direct lobby assistance, and complications if dispatch is shared on the same frequency with neighboring towns during regional incidents. Council also discussed related capital and operating lines in the police budget including accreditation (the chief said maintaining accreditation reduces insurance costs and preserves policies and SOP updates), training, and equipment requests.
Quotes and specifics: “Outsourcing dispatch eliminates our control to hire and train… it eliminates priceless institutional and jurisdictional knowledge,” the chief said. Administrator DeCarlo said the first-year costs could be high but that recurring costs offered possible multi‑year savings: “we’re anticipating the difference to be around $40,000.”
What’s next: Council directed staff to provide the underlying spreadsheets and cost breakdowns; the issue was not decided and will return for further review as part of budget deliberations. The chief also reviewed organizational staffing and explained the current lieutenant/sergeant/corporal structure needed to sustain a four‑squad, 12‑hour schedule without increasing overtime.
