Assembly narrows FOIL exemptions to three‑year renewable terms, citing transparency
Loading...
Summary
Lawmakers approved A.1410‑a requiring entities that seek FOIL exemptions for records submitted to state agencies to reapply every three years; proponents said the change reinforces public access, while critics warned of administrative burdens and inadvertent disclosures if renewals are missed.
Assemblymember Rosenthal urged adoption of A.1410‑a to reinforce the Freedom of Information Law’s presumption of public access by preventing indefinite FOIL exemptions for records submitted to state agencies. She said exemptions would run for three years and require an application for renewal at least 60 days before expiry.
Skeptics on the floor, including Assemblymember Walsh and others, raised concerns about the administrative workload for hundreds of agencies and about the risk that businesses or agencies might miss renewal deadlines and thereby inadvertently lose protections for genuinely sensitive materials. Rosenthal responded that the bill is forward‑looking, prospective only, and intended to increase transparency while allowing truly proprietary materials to remain protected via agency review and appeal procedures.
Debate focused on which entities are covered (state agencies and authorities), whether state commissions fall under the same rule, the mechanics of the 60‑day renewal window, and whether the bill should include flexibility for late filings. After floor explanation and exchange, the Assembly approved the bill (Ayes 97, Nays 46).
