Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Short Term Rentals topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Oglesby council approves short‑term rental permit for 125 Oakwood after heated public comment
Summary
After more than an hour of public testimony and debate, the Oglesby City Council voted 3‑2 to approve a short‑term rental permit for 125 Oakwood Avenue; opponents warned of noise and falling property values, while the applicant and supporters cited inspections, fines and local tax revenue.
The Oglesby City Council voted 3‑2 on July 21 to approve a short‑term rental permit for 125 Oakwood Avenue after extended public comment from both neighbors and the property owners.
Opponents in the meeting’s public‑comment period argued that allowing a short‑term rental (STR) in a single‑family neighborhood would harm community cohesion and lower property values. “Mister Bass has the right to apply for short term rental, but not at the expense of his neighbors,” Maria Borgie said, urging the council to honor its May 19 position against STRs.
Supporters, including an applicant representative, said the city’s STR ordinance includes inspections and enforcement, and that STRs bring modest economic benefits. An unnamed proponent pointed to a 5% STR tax that would generate revenue for city services and said the owners had completed a multi‑page city checklist and maintained insurance. “The power is with the council. If there is a violation on our part, you are free to revoke the license,” the proponent said.
Co‑owner Annie Basa, who identified herself as executive director of HealthCare Plus Senior Care, asked the council to “please give us a chance,” saying the family would screen guests, observe quiet hours and follow city rules.
Plan Commission member Jim Clinger told the council the ordinance requires an inspection in the first year and annual inspections thereafter, and outlined escalating fines for violations: $250 for the first infraction, $250 for the second, $500 for the third and $750 for the fourth, with a license suspension and hearing after the fourth violation.
Council debate focused on neighborhood character, housing availability and enforcement. Some council members urged limits or a cap on nonresident‑owned STR days; others said the ordinance as written gives the council tools to act quickly on violations. After a motion to reconsider and approve the permit, the roll call recorded Aldridge Aye, Cullinan No, McDermott Aye, Moyle No and Curran Yes, and the mayor said the approved license would be “on a very short leash.”
What happens next: the permit takes effect as approved; council members said they would monitor compliance and could suspend or revoke the license if enforcement problems arise. The meeting record shows the council also discussed revisiting the ordinance or referring changes to a future vote, but took no immediate action to change the code.
