Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the School Sports Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Superintendent Christy Haller asks board permission to sign petition urging separate private-school competition
Summary
Superintendent Christy Haller told the Exeter Township School District board she has been asked to sign a petition asking the PIAA and lawmakers to separate private/Catholic/charter schools from public-school championships because of recruiting advantages; board members debated fairness, prior bills and possible PIAA or legislative remedies.
Superintendent Christy Haller told the Exeter Township School District board on March 17 that she had been asked to sign a petition asking the Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic Association (PIAA) and state lawmakers to prevent private, Catholic and some charter schools from competing directly against public schools for certain championships.
Haller said the petition seeks a change because, she and several board members argued, some nonpublic schools recruit athletes and assemble teams that create an uneven playing field for public-school programs. "I would like to sign it on behalf of the district," Haller said, but she added she would not do so without first informing the board.
Board members traded examples of lopsided playoff matchups and social-media commentary about recent postseason scores. A member who coaches and parents in the audience described seasons in which Exeter teams faced heavily recruited opponents. "It's really unfair to our student athletes to have to compete against schools that are recruiting," Haller said. Another board member said some states hold separate private and public championships and cited South Carolina and New Jersey as examples where competition is separated at certain levels.
Members discussed prior efforts in Harrisburg, including an earlier House bill (House Bill 1983) that stalled in committee and references to House Bill 41, which board members said was focused on playoff structures. One trustee urged caution and recommended more information about how other states handled the issue before pursuing formal advocacy at the district level.
No formal motion or board vote was taken at the meeting. Haller said she brought the petition to the board for information and to check for objections before signing; most members expressed sympathy for the district’s competitive concerns but discussed pursuing either PIAA rule changes or legislative remedies.
The discussion concluded without a vote. The board will continue to monitor the petition and any developments from the PIAA or state legislature.
