Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Legal Affairs topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Compton municipal law chief lays out 10-year audit of claims and litigation, says oversight steps under way
Summary
Janine McIntyre, the city's inaugural municipal law division chief, told the City Council on Dec. 9 that the city currently has roughly 64 active lawsuits and that an outside audit flagged major deficiencies in documentation and litigation oversight; she outlined staffing and technology steps to tighten supervision.
Janine McIntyre, the City of Compton's municipal law division chief, presented a 10-year review of the city's legal and risk-management practices at the Dec. 9 council meeting, saying the city currently has roughly 64 active lawsuits on record.
McIntyre said the materials before the council summarized contract activity, claim filings, litigation trends and settlements. She told council that claims-processing and litigation exposure fluctuate with infrastructure projects and other operational shifts and that a recent external audit (PRISM) had identified substantial deficiencies in how the city documents and supervises claims and litigation.
The audit findings cited in the presentation included a documentation gap flagged at about 60% deficient, litigation-management concerns approaching 80% deficient and what the presenter described as supervision over claims and litigation rated as 100% deficient by the auditor. McIntyre said those findings helped prompt internal changes, including creating a municipal law division and establishing monthly oversight meetings with outside counsel.
Council members pressed her on recent defaults and settlement spikes. McIntyre said motions to set aside defaults had been filed quickly after staff became aware of service issues; of the most recent group of four defaults she described, two had been set aside, one had been dismissed and one remained subject to a forthcoming motion. On settlement trends, she said a small number of large payouts can produce spikes in any given year and that settlements are decided through a cost-benefit analysis that can be the most prudent course in particular cases.
McIntyre recommended a matter-management system to replace the city's largely manual, paper-based process for handling claims and outside-counsel reporting. She said improved technology and clearer invoice and reporting requirements for outside counsel would support claim audits, documentation and oversight.
Council members voiced support for the direction and asked staff to return with procurement options, timelines and costs. The presentation was framed by McIntyre as the beginning of a longer oversight and implementation effort rather than a final accounting of every case or dollar.
The council did not take a separate policy vote on the presentation itself; staff and the law division will return with follow-up material and formal proposals.
