Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Short Term Rentals topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council approves ordinance tying short‑term rental license revocations to convictions after lengthy debate
Summary
After extended public comment and debate, the South Padre Island City Council approved the first reading of an ordinance requiring criminal convictions — not citations or warnings — before revoking short‑term rental licenses, while asking staff to improve notice procedures and consider further stakeholder review.
The South Padre Island City Council voted to approve the first reading of ordinance 26‑01, which changes the city’s short‑term rental enforcement process to require a conviction before a property owner can face short‑term rental license revocation. Mayor (speaker 1) said the change is intended to reduce what legal staff described as “groundless” complaints and to protect the city from legal risk if licenses are revoked without the due‑process protections of a conviction.
Legal counsel (speaker 21) told council the ordinance targets frivolous complaints that send police to investigate but do not yield convictions, and that the change gives the courts — not administrative staff — the determinative step before license revocation. “We felt that a conviction should be required before you start taking someone’s license away,” the counsel said during discussion.
Vacation‑rental managers and property owners urged more process and participation before the change. Will Greenwood, who identified himself as owner of a local vacation‑rental company and president of the Vacation Rental Managers Association, said the ordinance and process have been “flawed” and requested a task force and a third‑party legal review to ensure revisions are practical and enforceable. Managers raised concerns about notification and response procedures for owners and agents, warning that poor communication could lead to unjust outcomes.
Council and staff discussed how warnings and citations are recorded and communicated. Wendy Delgado, director of operations (speaker 9), acknowledged a template error in the city’s notices that had caused confusion when property managers received paperwork labeled inconsistently: “We got user error—exhibit A,” she said, and pledged staff would correct notice templates and workflows.
After extended public comment — including residents who said habitual nuisance properties make life on the island difficult — councilmembers moved and seconded the ordinance reading. The motion passed by voice vote. Councilmembers directed staff to improve the notice and warning procedures and to work with short‑term rental stakeholders, while proceeding with the conviction‑based standard to avoid exposing the city to legal liability.
Next steps: the ordinance passed its first reading and will return for the required subsequent reading(s). Council asked staff to report back on corrected notice templates and implementation timelines before peak seasonal periods.
