Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
House Judiciary subcommittee hearing features partisan fight over overturning Plyler v. Doe
Summary
Republican members urged overturning the Supreme Court's Plyler v. Doe (1982), arguing the decision imposes fiscal and operational burdens on states; Democratic members and civil-rights witnesses warned that removing the ruling would harm children, public schools, and long-term economic outcomes. No vote was taken.
The House Judiciary subcommittee opened a hearing on "the adverse effects of Plyler v. Doe," with Republican members urging Congress and the courts to revisit the Supreme Court's 1982 decision that guarantees K'12 public education to children who are in the United States without lawful status.
Chairman Roy summarized his argument that Plyler was "constitutionally indefensible," told the panel "It's time for it to go," and framed the decision as an example of judicial overreach that forces states to subsidize education for children who are here illegally. He and other Republican members repeatedly cited estimates of local fiscal burdens and called on Congress to authorize states to collect students' immigration status for planning purposes.
Ranking Member Scanlon and other Democrats pushed back. Scanlon said the ruling has been "settled" law for decades and pointed to multiple analyses asserting net fiscal and economic gains from educating children regardless of status, including a $93 billion net benefit cited for Texas and broader lifetime gains…
Already have an account? Log in
Subscribe to keep reading
Unlock the rest of this article — and every article on Citizen Portal.
- Unlimited articles
- AI-powered breakdowns of topics, speakers, decisions, and budgets
- Instant alerts when your location has a new meeting
- Follow topics and more locations
- 1,000 AI Insights / month, plus AI Chat
