Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Zoning topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Residents press Sheboygan council to slow zoning rewrite and seek transparency on Gartman/TID plans
Summary
Multiple public commenters warned that a proposed zoning code rewrite and the Gartman/TID development could shift decision-making to staff, limit public hearings, and raise affordability and transparency concerns; council approved a separate Timberwood Meadows TID agreement amid debate over affordability targets.
Several residents urged the Sheboygan Common Council to slow or halt a comprehensive rewrite of the city's zoning code and to provide more transparency around the Gartman/TID housing proposals.
Lisa Salgado, a resident of Fourth Street, told the council she has "serious concerns about the second draft of the zoning ordinance," saying it adds procedural and administrative rules that she said would allow staff to approve projects that meet ordinance standards without Plan Commission or council review. "This means industrial and commercial projects including potentially data centers could be approved without a plan commission vote, without a common council vote, and without a public hearing," Salgado said, urging the council to "stop this ordinance and keep zoning decisions where they belong with elected officials and the public."
Peter Jacobs and Rebecca Clark made similar points during public comment, questioning why Von Briesen was engaged for the rewrite without a council resolution and raising concerns that the Gartman Farm/TID process had not provided requested pro forma documents. Jacobs alleged the development contract awarded title to a developer and described substantial city subsidies — claims he asked the council to investigate; city staff said the development has a multi-year history of marketing and negotiation.
Director Zinar explained that staff had worked with a developer and that committee members had asked staff to pursue affordability options; he said the finance and personnel committee had sought 20% affordability but the developer indicated that level was not feasible. Devin, representing the developer, described product types targeted at "workforce/attainable housing," saying single-family and twin home units were expected to be priced in the mid-hundreds of thousands in the plan and that smaller lots and floorplans were part of the effort to make units more attainable.
Council debate later turned to a separate resolution authorizing a tax-increment-district development agreement with Timberwood Meadows LLC for property between Menning Road and Stahl Road (Resolution 1902526). Director Zinar walked through parcel history and recent housing studies; several council members pressed for clearer affordability commitments. The council approved the Timberwood Meadows TID development agreement on roll call (7 ayes, 3 noes).
Council also moved procedurally to discharge an earlier version of the zoning ordinance from the Plan Commission and to file that first document so the council can proceed with a second, substantially revised document; the revised rewrite was referred to the committee of the whole for further consideration.
Where speakers made factual claims about contracts, subsidies or statutory compliance, those claims remain the speakers' assertions on the record; council and staff responses are recorded in the meeting packet and the transcript but do not resolve all outstanding public requests for pro forma or FOIA materials.
The council did not adopt a final zoning ordinance at this meeting; procedural steps instead cleared the way for further review and public engagement scheduled through forthcoming committee meetings and public open houses.
