Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Urban Infrastructure topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission denies sycamore removal request at 2243 North Indian Hill Boulevard
Summary
The commission unanimously denied a property owner’s request to remove a California sycamore at 2243 North Indian Hill Boulevard after staff said the tree is in good health, suggested watering and discouraged installing a root barrier because of likely longer‑term harm.
Staff presented the request to remove a single California sycamore at 2243 North Indian Hill Boulevard and recommended denial.
Staff findings and context Carrie Delman, community services manager, said the sycamore is approximately 20 inches in diameter, about 30–45 feet tall, valued at just over $6,000, and currently in good health though showing some signs of water stress. Delman summarized property‑owner concerns: infrastructure damage (settled claims totaling $25,746), a claimed new allergy to the tree’s pollen (no documentation provided), and nuisance debris and sap on vehicles.
Feasible mitigations discussed Staff and the city’s contractor (West Coast Arborist) inspected the site and confirmed installing a root barrier is technically feasible but not recommended because it is temporary, can push roots deeper and risk utilities, and may eventually increase damage. Staff suggested increased homeowner watering and additional trimming as practical mitigation; staff estimated a root‑barrier installation cost at about $1,700 and owner‑paid removal/replanting at approximately $1,800.
Commission action Commissioners reviewed the tree committee’s prior consideration and agreed the sycamore did not meet the city’s hazardous‑tree criteria. Commissioner Scott Tu moved to deny the request and Commissioner Brower seconded. The motion passed unanimously with Commissioner Silva absent.
Follow up Staff recommended denial but offered the owner the option to pay removal and replacement and encouraged practical steps (increased watering and working with staff) to reduce nuisance impacts.
