Board denies Michael Taylor’s variance request for East Okoboji Beach Township property

The Dickinson County Board of Adjustment denied Michael Taylor’s request for a variance for property identified at 25701 Martin Drive in East Okoboji Beach Township during its Aug. 26 meeting.

Taylor told the board he wants to move to the property to “take care of ailing parents,” and he said the family — including “10 grandkids” — needs space. He also said the planned house would include a basement safe room for storms. Builder Dan Tuttle explained the lot is oddly shaped and said the safe room is inside the basement; Tuttle told the board he did not include the safe-room details on the original print because he “only asked for the house plans” from Consumers Lumber.

Planning staff read letters from Beth Westphahl and Randall and Jaqueline Kramer. Neighbor Stan Jacobs spoke in support of the variance generally but objected to “the north 5 feet on Martin Drive, as that would block their view.” Other public commentators included Denny Taylor, who described the property’s family history, and Bonnie Jacobs, who said preserving her lake view matters after back surgery.

Board members questioned whether a well exists on site, the location of the air conditioner and how trees and lot shape affect setbacks and sight lines. Kardell (Planning & Zoning Administrator) and the builder discussed water, tree removal and the safe room’s location during the hearing. After board discussion, Alex Oponski moved and Cami Wills seconded a motion to vote; the minutes record that the motion carried with a 5-0 tally and that the variance was denied. The transcript does not include a verbatim finding of fact or detailed rationale for the denial.

The board then moved to the next agenda item.