Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Administrative Law topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
House approves measure expanding when legislative leaders can intervene in agency court appeals
Summary
Senate file 2039, as amended on the floor to include language from HF853 and to require de novo review in certain appeals, passed the House after debate over separation of powers; the suspension of rules and amendment passage were approved by recorded votes.
The House passed Senate file 2039 with floor amendments that expand when legislative leaders may intervene in judicial review of agency action and add language from a prior bipartisan bill clarifying review standards.
Sponsors said the amendments will allow majority and minority leaders of each chamber to intervene in court proceedings regarding agency action to ensure legislative intent is considered. The floor amendment added text from HF853 (previously passed 96–0) that requires de novo review in certain appeals, which supporters described as improving access and leveling the playing field for taxpayers.
Opponents warned that the changes risk legislative intrusion into the judicial branch. A member argued the measure represents an "unwarranted intrusion into the judicial branch" and called it a potential "power grab" by the legislature; sponsors replied that the intent is to protect legislative intent and ensure elected representatives' voices are heard when agency interpretations appear to contradict statute.
Leadership temporarily suspended the rules to consider the amendment; the suspension succeeded by recorded vote. The amendment and the bill as amended were then passed on final reading; the clerk recorded the final vote as 71 ayes, 24 no, 5 absent when reported on the floor.
Supporters said the change will make appeals more accessible to taxpayers and align interpretations with legislative intent; opponents emphasized separation-of-powers concerns.
