Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Short Term Rentals topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
East Dundee planners back STRs in business zones; residential STRs to require special use
Summary
On Dec. 4 the Planning & Zoning/Historic Commission recommended short‑term rentals be permitted in business districts and allowed in R1–R3 residential zones only via special use, urging licensing, inspections and possible owner‑occupancy or minimum‑night limits; the recommendation moves to the Village Board.
The East Dundee Planning & Zoning/Historic Commission on Dec. 4 voted to recommend that the Village Board allow short‑term rentals (STRs) as a permitted use in business districts and treat them as a special use in R1, R2 and R3 residential districts, with licensing and inspection requirements to follow.
Franco, speaking for village staff, said the proposed amendment would add a short‑term rental definition and enable the village to require licensing, inspections and an amendment to the village’s hotel‑tax rules. "This would be for short... shorter than 30 days," Franco said when describing the definition staff proposed.
An emailed public comment from Jan Andree, read into the record, urged the commission to oppose allowing STRs in residential neighborhoods because of concerns about neighborhood character and transient renters. "I am opposed to the concept of being implemented in the residential areas," the email said, citing neighbors’ pride of ownership and potential behavior problems.
Commissioners discussed a range of mitigations: limiting STRs to owner‑occupied properties, banning single‑night rentals to prevent “party houses,” capping the number of licensed units, and relying on licensing and adjudication rather than zoning enforcement to address violations. The village attorney said communities commonly use owner‑occupancy limits and minimum‑night stays as license conditions: "I've seen limitations like, you cannot do single night rentals, to avoid party houses." Commissioners also raised housing‑stock concerns, with one commissioner noting the village’s comprehensive plan indicates about 14.8% of land use is residential and expressing worry that whole‑house STR conversions could reduce long‑term housing.
After discussion the commission voted to recommend that STRs be permitted in business districts and allowed in residential zones only by special use, and to forward that recommendation to the Village Board so staff can draft licensing provisions and additional limits for Board consideration.
Next steps: staff will prepare materials for the Village Board, which will review and may adopt a zoning amendment and implementing licensing rules.
(Reporting based only on the commission meeting transcript.)
