Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Environment topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Residents urge stronger enforcement of SLD landfill consent order; council agrees to send letter to FDEP
Summary
A coalition of residents (HALO) told council they documented repeated H2S odor violations at the SLD landfill and asked the city to press the state for a stricter, enforceable consent order; council voted to send a supportive letter and encouraged community use of the state complaint system.
Members of Home Owners Against Landfill Odors (HALO) presented an extended briefing to Punta Gorda City Council describing long‑running hydrogen sulfide (H2S) odors from the SLD landfill and asked for city support in pressing the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) for a stronger, enforceable consent order.
Kim Kitkco of HALO said volunteers had tallied complaints and reviewed state records, concluding the landfill’s operations have exceeded allowable odor conditions and that the historical consent decree (2016) was weak and poorly enforced. “Did you know that SLD odors can reach over 12,000 residents in both Lee and Charlotte County?” she asked the council, adding that only a small fraction of affected residents currently know how to file odor complaints with state agencies.
HALO asked the city to send a formal letter supporting a stronger consent order with measurable triggers, third‑party oversight, tighter timelines for closing completed cells and higher penalties for violations. The group also proposed the city consider administrative petitions and non‑renewal or suspension of city contracts with SLD until the company demonstrates effective odor controls.
Council members and staff asked procedural questions; legal counsel noted the city’s options are limited but that joint letters and administrative petitions by affected local governments can amplify pressure on the state. After discussion the council moved and approved a motion to send the letter to FDEP in support of stronger, enforceable terms and to help publicize how residents can file odor complaints.
ŇWhat the HALO presentation said: HALO reported (1) approximately 3,000 odor complaints over 10 years in FD records, (2) documented operational practices (large uncovered active working areas, slow closure of closed cells) that can exacerbate H2S emissions, and (3) recommended specific technical changes for the consent order, including continuous H2S monitoring and a lower enforcement trigger than the draft order proposes.
Council action: Council approved a motion to send a letter urging FDEP to adopt measurable, enforceable terms and to amplify public awareness of the state smell‑complaint process. Council and staff also agreed to coordinate with Charlotte County on a joint approach.
Provenance: HALO presentation begins SEG 2368 and the council motion to send a letter was made and passed at SEG 2709–2715.
