Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Governance topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commissioners press for fairer use of Robert’s Rules after complaints about chair’s interruptions
Summary
Commissioners debated whether meetings should follow Robert’s Rules more closely after members complained the presiding chair skipped speaker queues and sometimes spoke before sponsoring commissioners. County counselor acknowledged small-board exceptions but urged fairness and respect for the rules.
Commissioner Willington pushed for clearer, more even application of Robert’s Rules of Order during the Clay County Board of Commissioners’ meeting, saying sponsoring commissioners are “not always called on to speak first” and that the presiding commissioner sometimes “skips the queue.” Willington told the board these practices have prevented sponsoring members from framing or closing debate on agenda items.
Kevin Graham, the county counselor, reminded the board that Robert’s Rules is adopted by ordinance and said small-board exceptions exist, but urged the commission to apply the rules fairly. “We wanna follow Robert’s Rules, but we don’t wanna be slaves to Robert’s rules,” Graham said, adding that the chair should not “abuse that position or dominate the conversation.”
Several commissioners supported reviewing and clarifying procedure. Commissioner Whittington (speaking from the floor) said his microphone had been cut off when he brought a discussion and that the presiding commissioner had replied between queued speakers, which he said felt unfair. Commissioner Lawson said studying the rules would bring “decorum” to meetings and help the board “be more professional.” Commissioner Carpenter said he supported following the rules while keeping meetings productive.
Board members discussed specific points: the sponsoring commissioner should be recognized to open and close debate on motions; a presiding officer for a small board can participate but should not use the role to sidestep the queue; and privileged motions (for example, to table) should end debate rather than be used to continue it. The county counselor described these as partly gray-area issues where small-board practice allows more flexibility but said the overarching principle is fair, respectful facilitation.
No formal vote or ordinance revision was taken at the meeting. Commissioners agreed to review Robert’s Rules and suggested the county counselor or staff provide guidance and references so the board can adopt clearer, mutually agreed procedures at a future meeting.
